The Guardian
topics

Video: Michael Kinsley @ The ‘Separate But Equal’ Digital Ellies

The greatest benefit of moderating a session at the Magazine Publishers Association conference on e-reading today was the chance to witness Slate founding editor Michael Kinsley’s induction into the Magazine Editors’ Hall of Fame. I caught his wry acceptance on video but missed the chance to record Nicholas Lemann’s touching introduction of the man a lot of people think of as the definition of “editor.” (The video embedded below is brief but a little shaky at times due to operator error; for those of you who prefer, here’s an mp3.)

Not coincidentally, this all took place during the inaugural National Magazine Awards for Digital Media, the first time the American Society of Magazine Editors has honored editorial achievement on the web and mobile devices in the same way as print. Or, as Kinsley put it, after years of struggle by ASME, “I think the Supreme Court said it best in Plessy vs. Ferguson, ‘separate but equal.’” The winners, led by NewYork.com’s award for general excellence, are listed here. Kinsley bridges both: in addition to Slate, his other magazine resume lines include editing roles at The New Republic, Harper’s Magazine, The Economist, and The Washington Monthly. He is now a senior editor for The Atlantic, advising on The Atlantic Wire, among other things. 

Mar 18, 2010 5:25 PM ET

Michael Kinsley

Share

Posted In: Media & Publishing, Magazines, ellies, magazine publishers association, michael kinsley

  • Sean

    @denver software developers - The fact that Apple opened up a very lucrative marketplace to bedroom developers motivates a great many of them to get on with developing for the platform.  It in no way "squashes" developers.

    Platforms with very limited potential for making money fill the major of developers with bored apathy.

  • An open source phone that allows a community to ad to its applications will ultimately be great for the consumer.  The grip Apple has on iPhone development squashes the group of potential developers.

  • Timm

    The free/not free point is interesting only to handset manufacturer looking for an OS,  so Android mostly hurts WinMo as I suspect Acer, HTC will gravitate to a superior and free OS.

    Users mostly don't give a *** about OS, it is the experience, design and ecosystem that matters.

  • Google Fan

    @mathiastck -

    The iPhone app platform is free too.  It only costs when you decide to purchase a "non-free" application from it.  At some point the Android platform will need to be the same (a mixture of free and paid apps) or the whole economics of it break apart.  What good does the Android platform do for the carrier (or manufacturer or developers) if revenue can't be driven from it…why would any of them bother?

  • The previous comments seem to be ignoring price.  Android is free.  Also Google doesn't have to become a hardware or consumer retail marketing expert.  It's the phone's manufacturers, and the carriers selling the phones that will still be most invested.  Google has simply provided them a great free tool that allows these groups to cheaply sell advanced features.

    People weren't choosing phones for J2ME support, but they did choose them for the applications that J2ME provided.  IM is a deal breaker for many people, etc.

    I know people that want will make sure their next phone supports Shazam, or Pandora.

  • Google Fan

    I love Google's products but agree wholeheartedly with Sean's thoughts.  It's not about open source vs. proprietary.  It's about user experience.  and iPhone is the clear leader right now.

    On a side note, the Palm Pre does appear to be a pretty slick device but it will suffer from being on the Sprint Network (at least out the gate) and from a less developed app platform.

    Informa Telecoms & Media clearly is missing something

  • Joe Anonymous

    The entire premise of the analysis is flawed. The analyst makes a wild assertion that BECAUSE Android is open source, it WILL BE more successful than iPhone. The flaws in this logic are apparent when one considers the relative market share of Windows and Linux.

    Perhaps Android MIGHT beat iPhone some day. But please give some rational justification and back it up with evidence. At this point, there is no evidence at all to support this assertion—other than the religious belief that Open Source will always win.

  • Sean

    I love OSS and regularly uses OSS tools and other software for programming work.

    But consumers buying a phone do not give fiddler's fart about whether or not products are made from open source, closed source or bloody chili sauce. 

    What they do care about is that a good product does things that they want in an easy, professional and preferably efficient way.  They care that the UI is highly discoverable, classy looking and does what they expect.  And of course they care about pricing.

    I would expect that the masses (and make no mistake it is the masses and their purchases that will crown a product or reduce it to an also ran) will largely ignore the gphone after an initial spike of curious early adopter purchases.

    The gphone will most likely end up in a tussle with the Palm Pre over 2nd place. I would also expect it to place 3rd eventually since the Pre seems (at least it's demos) to be far slicker it's competitor.

    RIM has a fairly entrenched corporate user base .  i wouldn't think that that demographic would indulge in platform "bed hopping" to any great extent (although I must admit to being surprised at the numbers of people from this group adopting the iPhone as their new platform).

    MS Win mobile 7 will impact the mobile smart phone world with a dull ineffectual thud as it arrives into a market already settling on other platforms.  A collective shrug it's only acknowledgment. (Except for in MS dominated corporate IT groups who will likely show it to each other in glee).

  • Synthmeister

    Let's see, Google has how much experience in the OS space, online retail space, hardware/software integration and consumer electronics space?

Unhealthily Obsessed With Mobile Content | mocoNews Newsletter

Know something we don’t?

Send Us a News Tip

All tips are anonymous and untraced.

Sponsors

Contributors