The Guardian
trending topics

T-Mobile USA’s $80 Unlimited Plan Avoids Price War

  • Comments Comments (View)
  • Text Size: A A

T-Mobile USA, the US’s fourth largest carrier, is the latest to offer up a flat-rate unlimited, no-contract plan as it tries to shore up its deteriorating subscriber base.

The pricing of its “Even More” plans that appeared Monday are much less aggressive than analysts had expected—and feared. The industry had been bracing itself for a $50 unlimited all-inclusive plan that could have kicked off a price war. Instead, the carrier, owned by German telecoms giant Deutsche Telekom (NYSE: DT), is offering a $79.99 contract-free plan that includes unlimited talk, text and internet surfing, and a cheaper $50 one that only includes unlimited voice. As Reuters points out, this is actually only a 20 percent discount on its $99.99 two-year unlimited contract plan, which gives customers cheaper cellphones.

But how much will the new plans actually help T-Mobile to lure and keep subscribers? Larger rival Verizon (NYSE: VZ), the remaining holdout with no similar plan, said in its earnings call on Monday, that it had been carefully watching T-Mobile’s price changes, but that it didn’t see “a need to respond” to them. “We really don’t see it breaking new ground,” said Verizon EVP and CFO John Killian.

It’s a fair assessment, especially considering for $30 less, a customer can get a similar plan at Sprint’s Boost. Moreover, the plan probably won’t help with T-Mobile’s larger problem with its subscribers—it’s losing its more higher paying customers at a faster clip than its lower paying ones, and replacing those more lucrative customers with less lucrative ones. In its Q2 results released in August, T-Mobile USA, the carrier managed to add 325,000 new customers, compared with 415,000 in Q1, and 668,000 in the same quarter a year ago. Of those new net adds, 268,000 were prepaid customers. Most analysts believe that the pricing was better for the wider industry. Piper Jaffray analyst Christopher Larsen wrote in a research note, “...the new plans are more benign than investors’ initial fears and could relieve some pressure on wireless stocks,” but for T-Mobile the plans—stopping short of a price war—reveals how limited its options are in gaining new customers.

Oct 27, 2009 7:13 AM ET

T-Mobile Stick Together Photo: T-Mobile USA

Share

Posted In: Companies, T-Mobile, Verizon

  • otto

    Why T-mobil USA chrges you for person in canada called me. It seems no consumer protection for this greedy company.  it is completely unfair and imoral thing to make many the way t-mobil charges his own customer. Why somebody think the company is good while still it is robbing people?

  • Jennifer

    I was just wondering tonight, where do you go when customer service is giving you the run around?
    Now we know what's going on, Tmobile is now deducting minutes from our mobile to mobile convos!!!! We just found out last night! And they wouldn't fix it? Just gave me 50 extra mins instead? Y? So I can call back tomorrow with the same problem? Next week can't come fast enough for me!

  • dp

    Jennifer, you are wasting your time venting here.  The T-Mobile reps are backed against a wall and don't have anything to do so they are trolling the blogs to fight for their jobs.  Take that energy and place it on your state reps desk.  Verizon has excellent customer service.  They aren't perfect but they are great!

  • Mobile Phones UK

    I’m disappointed that I’m unable to get the activation fee waived despite 4 years with T-Mobile.

    Thank you once again for the alert

    http://www.mobile-cell-phones.co.uk/

  • Greyfoxzero

    Tmobile and Verizon meet in an alley. Tmobile pulls a knife, verizon a gun. Tmobile acts all big and takes a swipe at verizon and gets pistol whipped. Then Verizon stabs Tmobile with its own knife. Now Tmobile is lying there bleeding money. Thats essentially what this article is saying. In the cell phone industry Tmobile just brought a knife to a gun fight.

  • Jennifer

    Wow! Just so ya know kid, it's not the phones that have the issue! It's the company!

    My phones are fine. I happen to like them. Of course there are better ones. But that has nothing to do with the fact that customer service is not taking care of the problem they are telling me their computer is having!

    But it's all good, I'm getting rid of this nonsense and going with a better company this week! So good luck kid!

  • laughs@jennifer

    sidekick,,rocker ..lol you choose your phones well

  • Jsad

    T-mobile is going down the tubes this is coming from a sales rep.

  • jennifer

    Now you see, that's exactly the grade school nonsense we get when we call about our bill!
    Whether we have a flex account or a 2 yr contract, it should not matter! If there is a computing error with these minutes,(which there is) and it is obvious, then it should be fixed!

    Oh and so you know, I have a 2 yr contract! I started on the flex pay so I paid way more for my sidekick and Rocker than anyone with a contract! So you would think that Tmobile isn't interested in losing any kind of customer!
    But, just like I was wrong the first day I paid for these phones, I am wrong now trying to stay with this company.

  • Dylan

    Regardless of the reduced rates potentially possible via the "Even More" and "Even More Plus" plans, if you're still feeling like the pricing here is rather steep in general, I thought I'd add a tip for minimizing the monthly bills. I actually work for the consumer advocacy division of the company Validas, where we electronically audit and subsequently reduce the average cell bill by 22 percent through our website, http://www.fixmycellbill.com (and I'll mention that 22 percent equates to over $450 per year for the average user). Put simply, Validas guards against frivolous and unnecessary charges that inflate your cell bill more than it should be for your usage. You can find out for free if fixmycellbill.com can modify your plan to better suit your needs by going to the website.

    For more info, check out Validas in the media, most recently on Fox News at http://www.myfoxtampabay.com/dpp/consumer/conlaw/lower_cell_phone_bills_072409 .

    Good luck to everyone reading on lowering your cell bills, particularly in light of this tough economy.

    Dylan
    Consumer Advocacy, fixmycellbill.com

  • Scott

    It's true it's not entirely groundbreaking prices but things need to be competitive. Different carriers have different prices. However, when talking about family plans, none of the big 3 carriers can match T-Mobile's Even More Plus for Families plans.

    Verizon, Sprint, and AT&T charges $120 (not including taxes) for 700-750 minutes and unlimited text shared among 4 lines. T-Mobile now offers the same plan for just under $100 (taxes included). The only catch here however, is that new AND existing customers would need to pay up $35/line in activation fees and purchase phones at unsubsidized prices from its carrier, purchase phones elsewhere, or use existing phones. I'm disappointed that I'm unable to get the activation fee waived despite 4 years with T-Mobile. However, that's what you get for a plan that cheap.

    If I do pay the $35/line activation fees for the above plan I mentioned, then stay with T-Mobile for 6 months to break even on the savings, then it's $25/month in savings thereafter when compared to the other big 3 plans.

  • TOM

    Jennifer you are stupid. first off, your the idiot for buying a sidekick.. as a t-mobile retail rep, no one, i mean no one has recommended it for 14 months now, so take responsibility for being a stupid idiot that needed to have that cool sidekick. secondly it sounds like you are on flexpay and what you need to understand is, that you are one of those customers that t-mobile does not mind losing… your credit sucks and you couldnt get approved for an account where they could fix that issue… go pay that 500 dollar deposit at the other carrier and be gone…

  • Jennifer

    Hmm? Maybe before you get on the "my fellow customer service reps are right and people should take responsibility for their actions," maybe you should have read what was written! Or maybe you should sit on the phone and hear what they told me! "Oh yes, 30 mins were deducted on the weekend, and oh yes here is another overlapping, double min mistake, but we can not fix it bexcause you did make the call! We don't know which one is right? Well, yes over the last year your average monthly usage is only 700 out 1000 mins but this time it shows that you used 1000 mins in 8 days? You'll have to wait til the next bill cycle and print out your phone call report and add it all up and then call us back with the difference. And we'll see what we can do. Oh and yes we see the 4 other times in the past you've had to have minutes replaced because of computer tally error but I don't know what to tell you!"

    Are you serious? What do you do with that? What do you do when you sat on the phone with 1 for an hour an line by line went thru the bill and found the mistakes and when you said, that is a mistake and that is and that is and that is and that is, and they say well it shows that you made "A" call so there's nothing we can do!

    Are you kidding me? I have these calls recorded and it's all going to the Better Business Buraeu. I'm done.

    I do take responsibility for my actions. Why can't they follow the same rule?

    I have unlimited text, nights & weekends, web and mobile to mobile and I hate talking on the phone! I text all the time, so where'd my mins go? Hmm? Could they be with the $24.99 credit that Tmobile had to give me for my Sidekick Data sevrices being down for over a week? Hmm kind of convenient that my minute usage reflects that of a $105 plan and not that of a $136 plan??? Oh and how come my next bill $111??? I pay $136 each month? Have for over a year? Got an explanation for that?

  • MichaelT

    I have to agree with the article, these aren't really groundbreaking prices. I use a cheaper alternative already in the form of Straight Talk, which costs me only $45 for unlimited everything, whilst still being on a true nationwide network (Verizon's). So T-Mo is not even getting close to being a threat to some other lower priced carriers.

  • Robert

    Don't blame t-mobile reps. T-mobile reps care about the customer we try to help out every customer. People think customer service is giving money away. T-Mobile is not a non profit orginization. They are in the business to make money. Now if customer care reps gave money away to everyone their would be no profit and it would put the company out of business.  People do not take responsibility for their actions.  Americans do not like to take responsibility for their actions. They want a bail out. People think customer service is when we give into the demands of everyone. Customer service is a balancing act. We an advocate for the customer. However we also have to balance company policy. We try to help out as much as possible but people need to really learn to take responsibility. If i go over my minutes I go over my minutes. Its my fault. People get angry and call in because they want customer service to credit their accounts for something they did. Its your responsibility to check your minutes and to make sure you are not going over. Customer service reps are not baby sitters and we are not parents. I'm tired of people thinking that the customer is always right that is a mistake. Customers are not always right and because we have encouraged this practice people think its okay not to take responsibility for their actions.

  • Jennifer

    Ya know, maybe if TMobile's customer service reps, cared about their customers, they might not lose them so fast! I am a tmobile cust and believe me, they are crooked! I pay over $125 a month for 2 phones, and everytime they have to credit me because service goes down, they make up for it by double charging my 1000 whenever mins so I run out faster and have to buy a prepaid card to talk! This is ridiculous! This time they sucked up 1000 mins in 8 days! And won't give them back! How can they expect to keep customers this way? I know I am quitting and I don't care about their stupid $200 early termination fee for each phone!

Unhealthily Obsessed With Mobile Content | mocoNews Newsletter


Sponsors

Contributors