Lightsaber App Coming To App Store—Again; Is Apple’s Vetting Process Full Of Holes?
Remember the basic lightsaber iPhone App that captured the hearts of Star Wars fans? It was free, but it was also a blatant case of copyright infringement and Apple (NSDQ: AAPL) was eventually forced to pull it from its store’s shelves. No worries Luke fans, it’s back. THQ Wireless, which has a long-term global exclusive on all of Lucas Film’s mobile game properties, is launching it later this month. Lightsaber Unleashed is expected to launch Sept. 16 to coincide with a new console game from the Star Wars franchise, Star Wars: The Force Unleashed. Star Wars fans that own an iPhone might be happy to know that THQ (NSDQ: THQI) plans to release the more feature-rich version of the game for free as well. Features will include: multiple lightsaber colors that correspond to the main characters, and other music and dialogue.
While this resolves any licensing issues surrounding the lightsaber application, it highlights many oversights on Apple’s part as the sole steward of its App Store. Does Apple really do its part to vet applications for device stability issues and potential legal ramifications? After all, this is a company with a catalog of more than 8 million songs on iTunes and it’s successfully kept illegal songs out. Given that the App Store is on such a smaller scale, it doesn’t seem like Apple is doing its best to vet out the illegal ones. Or, what Apple is likely figuring out is that it is much more difficult to sort through all the submissions than it originally led on. Bugs are easy to spot. But checking the authenticity of an application is a more time-intensive process that would be difficult to automate. A Star Wars-related application seems like an obvious thing to check on, but that’s not the case for most applications. This lightsaber application is simply another example of Apple’s newbie status in the mobile content space, a business littered with companies that excel at one or maybe a couple tasks but leave other duties to better-equipped partners. Carriers make deals with aggregators for this very reason; rather than reinventing the wheel and absorbing the burden on their own, let someone else deal with all the testing and rights issues. Instead, Apple wants it all, and so it will have to do all the painful work that model requires. Could the App Store continue to be profitable if Apple added a legal department to the mix? Perhaps that’s why Apple prefers to wait for cease-and-desist letters instead of vetting the authenticity of content it sells and distributes to millions of iPhones.
Posted In: Entertainment, Gaming, Companies, Apple, iphone

Comments (5)
Sep 4, 2008 5:55 PM
Apple requires that individuals and corporations who submit content, be it songs, games, or applications, warrant that they have attained the required rights to do so. It’s the only reasonable thing to do since in many cases it’s practically impossible to determine if someone has acquired the rights due to NDA and general communication issues. Imagine how horrible it would be if every single product that went up to the App Store required Apple to perform a legal vetting of the content ... they would release one title every six months!
Sep 5, 2008 4:57 AM
So Apple launches a new business and runs into a minor IP problem in the first few months. There’s not even a lawsuit, just a little delay while the legal stuff gets worked out. What’s the big deal? Overall the Apps store roll out has gone very smoothly.
Sep 5, 2008 5:50 AM
There are two fairly major inaccuracies in your story…
1 The application you featured was called PhoneSaber and not LightSaber
2 Apple did not pull the application, the developer did themselves after being contacted by THQ
The full story is at the phonesaber developer’s website here:
http://themacbox.co.uk/2008/08/phonesabers-future/
As the developer and THQ managed to reach agreement without Apple’s intervention whatsoever this really puts a whole new slant on your story.
This is not so much about Apple not being able to keep control of its app store content but proof that Apple’s hand picked developers are responsible enough to self regulate!
Sep 5, 2008 2:25 PM
Thanks for writing in Trotskiii. On your first point, there have been a couple lightsaber applications on the iPhone and so I just referred to the PhoneSaber application as a lightsaber app. On your second point, thank you pointing this out. While I realize that THQ went directly to the developer to have the application pulled, it still speaks volumes about Apple’s lack of oversight on the issue. I don’t see this as a story about a responsible developer, but rather one that developed unauthorized content borrowed from a strongly guarded brand. Either way, Apple helped distribute illegal content on its App Store and the developer was free and clear to do so until the rightful owners stepped in. Again, this is not something you see happening on its iTunes store.
Jan 21, 2009 8:09 PM
I agree with the comments more than the article.